ADVICE/OPINION/RELATIONSHIPS

Does The Truth Really
Set You Free?

A friend told me the other day that “women can’t handle the truth and don’t want the truth.” He said that if they did, they would not react the way they do when they get it.

He compared wanting the truth to wanting a million dollars or a new Mercedes. If a person really wants something, when they get it they are happy.

I say no, that is not how the truth works. So a man comes clean about cheating, lying or inappropriate behavior with another woman, and if a woman’s reaction is anything other than “It’s okay baby, I forgive you,” the man is quick to say “I knew I should not have been honest.” (Disclaimer: Not all men, but some.)

Truth Be Told …The truth is sometimes a hard pill to swallow. It is like a huge horse vitamin that makes you gag a little bit when it goes down. It may be hard to swallow, but it is definitely good for you. Some of us do want the truth even if we have a strong reaction to it when we get it.

I have had a couple of long-term relationships. In one of them, my significant other and I decided to be as honest with each other as we possibly could. We called ourselves, “living the truth.” That meant that we had to be honest about our feelings, our desires, our past, and our “mistakes.” I do not necessarily recommend this much honesty to everyone.

The relationship was going well (so I thought) and at some point my “Man” says that he has something to tell me. If someone starts the conversation like this I am always holding my breath. We were sitting on the bed in my apartment in the early evening. The television is off and the lights are low. I brace myself. I take a deep breath and he looks me in my eyes and just as he says IT, he looks away as if it is would be too difficult to look at me and speak the truth. He proceeds to tell me that he slept with someone else while he was away on vacation. The pain is indescribable. It was as if my spine disappeared and my body gave up from the agony piercing my heart. I slid off of the bed onto the floor and screamed so loud everyone in the building had to have heard me and stopped what they were doing right at that moment. I crawled into the bathroom, a few feet away, because it would have been too difficult to walk in my condition. I locked the door and cried in the dark until he left.

After I picked my self up off the floor, came out of the dark and all of my theatrics were over, I realized that this “truth thing” was not going to be easy. I am no longer with him, but that was not what broke us up. I did forgive him after a couple of weeks; some flowers, a little begging and about 2 million apologies. I have so much respect for this man today for doing something that most people would not have the guts to do.

I still maintain a high level of honesty in my relationships. It is not easy, but it works for me. It makes it easier to trust if we both agree on the level of honesty in the beginning. I also know I am truly accountable for my actions because of this commitment. Even after that incident I still want the truth. I still believe “honesty is the best policy.”

I wonder what most people believe. Is honesty is the best policy? OR do you subscribe to the idea that “What you don’t know won’t hurt you?”

I am curious. Tell me what you think.

Remember… It’s Always Love.

ReNina Minter is a former elementary school teacher who followed her passion and earned a Masters in Clinical Psychology. Minter is now a Certified Life Coach. Check out her website at www.CoachReNina.com. Her editorials are exclusive to Urban Thought Collective.


Email This Post Email This Post

Leave a Comment

Comments

June 21st, 2008 at 12:20 am Bam Saldana says:

Dam. That breakup description is downright drama. Can’t believe you two are still friends after all that. You all are more evolved than me.

June 21st, 2008 at 1:21 am Coretta Scott Queen says:

You know sometimes I prefer not to know. I trust my loved ones judgement and knowledge of me to determine whether or not they should tell me something. It’s worked so far for the good, the bad and the ugly.

June 21st, 2008 at 4:46 am Red Razor says:

i agree that honest is the best policy but you got ta have the backbone to backup the policy and most don’t.

June 21st, 2008 at 12:39 pm Roderick Watkins says:

Was this man really honest when he told you he cheated. Hear me out. I believed cheating was just a symptom indicating an underlying issue that needed to be communicated. If he was honest I think that he should have been able to communicate the true issue. The cheating was just a way to get your attention and a poor way at that. Unfortunately when we don’t know how to express ourselves will resort to such tactics instead of being honest that we are unhappy with the relationship and some adjustments need to be made. Its funny how we’ll resort to hurting those we love in an effort to not hurt them. I commend you on being able to remain friends. I do believe honesty is that best policy, but sometimes the truth is not always clear. Great article.

June 21st, 2008 at 1:12 pm Friendlee says:

Good for you for forgiving and staying true to your word that you wanted truth. Most of us don’t abide by our own rules which is a trip. If you going to set a rule for somebody else - like the boundaries Roderick talks about above - then you go to abide by ‘em yourself!

June 21st, 2008 at 5:47 pm Binta Rohan says:

Well said Sister Renina.

June 21st, 2008 at 10:02 pm Mayra Meji a says:

Hello,
Yes, I do believe that the truth does set you free, but we need to understand what this means. It means that when something is not working in our lives, the only way that it is going to ultimately not immediately better is by learning or accepting the truth. This is a process that takes time depending on the situation. In your case, I believe that he wasn’t honest with you from the get go and the cheating was who he really is. “Handsome is as handsome does.” He needs to correct that. It has nothing to do with you. You can’t blame yourself for other people’s inecurities and past experiences. I don’t think it is good idea to discuss your past with your mate, since the past is dead and you are no longer that so why bother digging up what you don’t like. I also think that the best time to get in a relationship is before you meet the guy not after you meet him. We need to know what is it that we want from a man and stick to that no matter how rich, poor, cute, average looking, or famous, not popular he might be. In the end what’s going to make you happy is what you heart needs, love, respect, honesty, loyalty, generosity. Someone who really cares about you from the bottom of his heart. This kind of man does not cheat, He knows it doesn’t pay.

Take care,
Mayra

June 21st, 2008 at 10:10 pm Chatty Cathy says:

I’m from the “What I Don’t know won’t hurt me” side of the room. I’m a sensitive softie so don’t tell me. Its probably unhealthy but it keeps me being a happy person.

June 22nd, 2008 at 1:17 am Faith says:

The truth shall set you free.

June 22nd, 2008 at 11:54 am Swanna says:

chatty cathy God bless ya but I have to know everything! I can’t imagine have all kinds of lies and untruths swirling around me and being blissfully (?) unaware.

June 22nd, 2008 at 1:19 pm ratty says:

Honesty first always and equivocably.

June 22nd, 2008 at 6:06 pm CraigH says:

You sound special. But what your first man did was dumb because most women would never forgiven him. She would have “punished” him one way or another for the rest of their lives. If he made a one-time mistake he should have kept it to himself. All men (or women) should. Most people do not have the capacity to truly forgive. I know what I am saying. I told my wife about a mistake 16 years ago and she has not loved me the same since. Because I believe God made marriage for “forever,” (and because we have kids) we have stayed together. But our marriage has never been the same and I regret every day not only what I did to dishonor the marriage but that I told her. Don’t do it, fellas!

June 22nd, 2008 at 8:53 pm ReNina Minter says:

Roderick- Good point that the “cheating” was a symptom of other issues. Cheating is however not always about the relationship or the other person. It is sometimes really about the person cheating and whatever issues that they bring into the relationship.

Mayra- I disagree that if a person makes the mistake of cheating (once) that that is automatically who they are. People make mistakes. We all make mistakes.

Craig- I am sorry to hear that you regret telling the truth and that your wife has never really forgiven you. It doesn’t always happen that way. Fellas keep telling the truth!

June 22nd, 2008 at 11:29 pm AfroDaddy says:

The truth is absolute - people are not. you should always take into account the person you are telling the truth to. For some (like CraigH) the truth just gave him a frustrating 16 years of life. Some truths (outside of cheating) are better left unsaid as the pain may heavily outweigh the gain. I personally believe in open, honest communication but once it comes out of your mouth you can’t take it back - even if your feelings change. Pray to find an honest evolved woman and be the same for her. In that scenario the truth will ultimately be the best way.

June 22nd, 2008 at 11:46 pm Destah Owens says:

I’m from the “I’d rather just know” side of things. I may be hurt (maybe more on the ego side unless I TOTALLY didn’t see it coming), but I’ll get over it. I’d rather hear the story about the “why” than have some BS about “next thing you know, it just happened…”

June 23rd, 2008 at 3:28 am Kettleblk says:

I ALWAYS want to know…. being ignorant to the facts only makes it harder later. Put it out on the table!

June 23rd, 2008 at 6:29 am Debbie Dallas says:

@Mayra I agree that we all need to know exactly what we want before diving in to any real relationship - then there is no drama or confusion or the dreaded ‘tryin to change my man’ syndrome that women get

June 23rd, 2008 at 10:29 am Sonny Dee says:

People cheat for all kinds of reasons boredom, fear or just wanting something different but can’t be your fault cuz you can’t fix what you don’t know is broken

June 23rd, 2008 at 11:50 am Jessica Hubbard says:

Maybe he told you so that you would break up with him! I can’t think of no other reason a man would do the deed, much less tell you about it they always go the roundabout way

June 23rd, 2008 at 12:49 pm wallruss says:

All of the “truth” isn’t terrible news. The challenge with telling the truth all the time is often the bother of having to explain every single thing for fear that omission will be considered a lie.

Related Material

Related Posts

Tag Cloud

Archival

Blog Archives by Month

Other UTC Blogs